OK, everything seems fine with this chair, but here are the minor quibbles and points I would address in a Mark II, if there is to be one.
I've just mentioned that the length of the seat is perfect and here's why. I read a report many years ago by a doctor (yes, a doctor) who advised on the design of Saab's car seats. He stressed how important it was to have proper support directly beneath the knee as this helped to relieve pressure on the lower back. With this Chub chair you get that as I've already mentioned, but the padding near the front edge could be placed directly along the edge and for the full 16” width of the seat instead of just the centre 12”. This would improve the comfort under your knees immeasurably.
Another point is the weight factor. It is without doubt a very heavy chair and unless I have my carp barrow I do not intend taking it to any venues where I have to walk much more than a couple of hundred yards. Could it be made lighter by getting rid of the reclining mechanism? I haven't as yet used it in anything but an almost upright position so I am now beginning to question that feature.
The arms are metal and get cold in the evening/night-time and this can penetrate your clothing even. It might be an idea to make the arms of some other warmer material or sell as an option, some sort of foam padded arm covers. Does that sound unreasonable?
I doubt that you would ever find a chair that you were happy with 100%; it would be a very rare item indeed and probably wouldn't suit other anglers. Overall I do like this chair, but I would love to see a lighter version made from aluminium tubing to make it easier to carry. Chub do make a much lighter chair, but it has a non-padded seat and back so perhaps a compromise between the two is required.
For me, it's a chair that I'm not going to carry too far, if at all. It will probably be lumped on top of my barrow, or I'll just use it in a near swim. I'll keep my smaller, lighter chair for the time being just in case I do want to rove around, but situations like that are becoming more and more rare these days.
Would I recommend it? Definitely, particularly for its strength and Chub's quality and reliability.
Rating: 8/10 |