Craig
the waters i was initially thinking of are well stocked; some might be consider 'puddle'type waters i/e dug within last 10 to 15 yrs & heavily stocked & pressured. I usually fish them after a particularly hard session on a difficult water, to restore my self confidence really. To allow myself some degree of self indulgent difficulty I will only surface fish for these fish.These fish are always right in the margins and stalking tactics needed multiple catches if fish in the 5 to 13lb are common on floaters if you approach it correctly. Again to increase my self indulgent difficulty I want to use a 'fly'.
My thoughts were to loose feed mixers,pellets,floating koi pellets whatever until pre-occupation / confident feeding was approached & then to flick out "bow & arrow cast" a spun deer hair fly al la trout pellet.
Now after Robs comment I wonder if a true fly orientated approach might work i.e a hare's ear well picked out guard hairs ginked up simulating a hatching sedge?, yep! grasping at straws but what are carp taking naturally speaking when 'clooping'?.
I see no reason not to actually cast for fish especially on larger waters but most semi local coarse waters that i'am considering do not allow for arialising 10 + yds of line to enable 'shooting' line, & as mentioned on a fly thread on FM the fly line would need to be dyed & the leader be of suitable strength & type.
I also have some concerns over; the playing / netting time, the chance of mouth damage via lost fish, recovery time etc. I would abandon this idea if anyone has any valid objections.