Spades VS eyed...

Paul H · Feb 13, 2008

I have once dabbled with spade end hooks (at Clattercote last year, I thought it might give me an edge) however I lost two fish on them due to my knots apparently being rubbish.

My question is do they really offer any advantage that outweighs the horrendously difficult whipping/knotting process?

The type of fishing I do is mostly for chub, barbel, bream and any other omnivorous fish usually with size 10, 12 or 14hooks and hair rigged or banded baits. Occasionally however I do get the maggot feeder out or a float and target smaller or shy biting fish and this really the type of situation where I wonder if I could be fishing more productively with spade ends.

What are your thoughts?

Mark Wintle · Feb 13, 2008

Paul,

There's no wondering about it; for smaller hooks the improved presentation from spade end hooks tied well is outstanding. I tie hooks as big as 10 using the spade-end knot.

Bob "chubber"Lancaster (ACA) · Feb 13, 2008

i think spade end hooks are better for presentation, but also paul like you i'm pretty crap at tieing them , so why not do what i do buy them ready tied. because of my eyesight i have big probs with tieing little hooks so now buy hooks to nylon.And must say i do catch a lot more fish.

Baz (Angel of the North) · Feb 13, 2008

Spade end hooks especially in the smaller sizes are far superior in the smaller sizes, say 16 and under. The whipping knot tied by hand is srong, neat, and reliable enough in a size 18 for chub. anything over a 14 and I would personally use an eyed hook.

TOM SAWYER · Feb 13, 2008

Matchman hook tyer makes knots a doddle---------

Skjelstad · Feb 13, 2008

Hook-tyer

Graham Whatmore · Feb 13, 2008

Paul, why give up tying your own because you havn't learned to tie them properly, wouldn't it be far simpler to learn how to tie them, after all it isn't exactly rocket science? If, like me now, your fingers aren't nimble enough to do it by hand then learn how to use a hook tyer which is so simple a women could do it. Instead of watching Corrie of a night just sit with some old line and practice tying your hooks, you may surprise yourself when you discover how easy it is, in fact all knot tying should be practiced until you are 100% confident in your knots because knots are the weakest link in your set up.

Lord Paul · Feb 13, 2008

I too have tried a hook tier - I'm just as rubbish as it as with hand - I now use the pretied -

TOM SAWYER · Feb 13, 2008

Never tried the Drennan tyer, but the Matchman one is easy to use and very reliable, I have total confidence in the knot, as Graham says, if your fingers aren't as nimble, its worth a look-----

Lord Paul · Feb 13, 2008

Tom - it's the Matchman I can't use

Bob "chubber"Lancaster (ACA) · Feb 13, 2008

if i make a load of hooklenghts at home i use a hook tier but on the banksidee my eyesite and fingers are so rotten i use hooks to nylon.

TOM SAWYER · Feb 13, 2008

That suprises me Paul, I can do a knot probably in 30 seconds its that easy, but I suppose it depends what you're used to------------

Lord Paul · Feb 13, 2008

Tom

The instruction were in french when I bought the thing - since printed English version of FM - still can't make a neat job of it with size 12 hooks and size 18 - forget it

TOM SAWYER · Feb 13, 2008

o be fair, it did take me quite a few attempts before I got the hang of it, but once you've got it, its really quick. The only downside is that you're never going to get quite the same length each time with your hooklength so may have to re-plumb,which is a bit of a nuisance but although I normally use hooks to nylon for that reason( laziness) , if I needed to, would be quite happy using it

Lord Paul · Feb 13, 2008

Tom - it's must just be me - I've spent a few hours trying the thing - I think - ah got it now then the hok length looks all crimped and the presentation looks poor - in the bin it goes - I can tie the bigger size hooks but like I said the presentation is poor.

Joey · Feb 13, 2008

<blockquote class=quoteheader>Lord Paul of Sheffield wrote (see)</blockquote><blockquote class=quote>Tom - it's must just be me - I've spent a few hours trying the thing - I think - ah got it now then the hok length looks all crimped and the presentation looks poor - in the bin it goes - I can tie the bigger size hooks but like I said the presentation is poor.</blockquote>
Stupid question I know M'lud but are you getting one of your underlings to moisten the line before you pull the Knot tight? Don't forget to have the line coming off the bend side of the hook.

Stevie the Pisc Artist · Feb 13, 2008

I like the knotless knot and palomar for eyed hooks and standard matchman tied know for my spade end.

If im completely honest the spade hooks are always presented better, I much prefer these especially on small hooks

Graham Whatmore · Feb 13, 2008

Its probably crimping because you are winding the turns on too tightly you only need to keep the line taut enough that the turns don't come off and don'tpull the line through too quickly as this will cause friction and also give you a twirly above the knot.

Practice is all that is neededlike I saidand its so so simple.

TOM SAWYER · Feb 13, 2008

I agree Steve, presentation is very good once you've got the knack----

Lord Paul · Feb 13, 2008

Looks like the knot tier is coming out tonight for another attemp - swear box will be ful lagain

Spades VS eyed...

Well-known member

Well-known member

Bob "chubber"Lancaster (ACA)

Guest

Baz (Angel of the North)

Guest

New member

New member

Senior Member

New member

New member

New member

Bob "chubber"Lancaster (ACA)

Guest

New member

New member

New member

New member

New member

Member

Senior Member

New member

New member