As previously stated in the initial thread, its no different to method feeder, pva bags, sticks,swimfeeder, the only difference being geographical.
Mr Big got flack for sticking to his guns, in all fairness, he had enjoyed success fishing this way, he said Frank Warwick enjoyed success using this method, and for that conviction he was given stick.
American carp fishing is far removed from English practice so far, pity that he was pilloried for his convictions, self-deprecation is always socially acceptable in the UK as opposed to what is deemed unseemly over-confidence.
It would appear FM has lost an overseas contributer because he held faith in a practice WE felt was old hat and not applicable to currently practised theory.