I wouldn't really use a whip for carp Daniel, unless it's really strong and the top section has been elasticated, There's a lot of margin poles around just now and they will do the job better than a whip. In summer I use the power section of my pole with a 14-18 elastic through 3 sections and fish pellets & paste, maggots, worm or corn. When the fish are feeding in the marging and competing they will eat just about anything you care to throw at them, getting them there and feeding in the first place can be the difficult part.