Its a good question Levi, but a tough one to answer unless the person answering actually knows the venue and thats the problem. Unfortunately these days with commercial carp fishing leading the way, each water may vary with preferred baits due to who is sponsored and what baits he uses and if he fishes the local lake or not, what tackle shop is closest and wants to sell bait etc or who's kicking off a serious pre-baiting campaign. The trick is to get down to the lake and ask, then ask some more then some more.
Most of the commercial baits work well in the winter. I'd say keep to a named brand such as mainline or solar or one of the bigger names, this is not based necessarily on best grade etc, but more based on amount being thrown in etc?
