Of course the carp fishing circus exists, and I think Gary is correct in his observations that it is acceptable for carp, but castigated for anything else.
I just wonder if it has anything to do with the fact that a) specimen carp hunting has been going on for much longer? b) their sheer size makes them a more obvious target?
c) As a result, the big 'uns soon became well known (i.e. not many uncharterd waters) d) do they live longer so by default are targetted more often?
I know for a fact that many people fish the RMC stretch of the River Lea for the very large chub, and every year 7lb'ers are landed. Now you are not telling me this stretch of river has numerous, uncaught 7's, yet every time someone lands one it is treated as such.
I have no issue people fishing for known fish, of any species, its just not my preference. And if, collectively, we cast aspertions on it, then we should beware of further accusations from noddy outfits like PETA.